The STI Clinic News > HIV and Circumcision Study Focuses on Bacterial Changes
# Sunday, 21 April 2013
Posted: Sunday, 21 April 2013 | Categories: HIV

Circumcision has often been the cause of numerous debates, with some reports of the effects of unconventional practices even becoming substantial legal controversies. However, it has also been a perspective to consider when researching the spread of HIV among men. What most studies appear to have found is that circumcision is related to a lower risk of getting HIV by up to 60%. Now a recent study has confirmed this and explained the underlying mechanisms for why this may be.

 

The study, which was published in mBio, was a prospective observational intervention study. In total, 156 uncircumcised men took part. After the researchers obtained baseline levels of bacteria in the genital area from all of the men, they were randomly split into two groups. In one of the groups all the men received circumcision, whereas the other group did not receive any intervention. Both groups were then followed up a year later, with the same measurements being taken to see the levels of bacteria in the genital area. These results were then compared to the initial baseline levels as well as between groups. The key findings indicated that the circumcised men had a non-significant increase in aerobic bacteria levels and an average of 81% decrease of anaerobic bacteria levels. Based on this the researchers concluded that circumcision positively affected the men’s penile ecosystem as a result of increased oxygen reaching previously covered skin. As a result, the prevalence of anaerobic bacteria levels decrease, which reduces the risk of inflammation that has been associated with making HIV infections more likely.

 

Several aspects of this study are commendable, with its prospective design perhaps also being its strongest point. Theoretically speaking the findings are useful to rule out other competing theories within this field. Although the findings certainly appear robust, it is also important to bear in mind that understanding underlying mechanisms within biological research requires in depth research to rule out variables and competing theories. As such, the most ideal scenario would be if these findings were replicated in another study. However, it is questionable whether this is feasible given that the execution of this type of research may be rather difficult. Nevertheless, if further studies were to gain an understanding of the underlying mechanisms for this phenomenon, then it would have a substantial impact on developing interventions.

 

We were not surprised to read about these findings as we are already well aware of other studies where male circumcision was associated with a lower incidence of HSV-2 lower risk of transmission of STIs (such as HPV and Trichomonas Vaginalis infections) to their female partners. Therefore, it should not come as a surprise if we write other significant studies within this field in the future.

 

How Our Service Works

  • Order your
    STI test online
  • Discreet package
    arrives next day
  • Provide a sample and post in pre-paid envelope
  • Access results online
How it works - order a test, provide sample and get results online

Telephone

UK +44 (0)20 7125 0367

Email

customerservice@thesticlinic.com

Address

2 Wingate Business Exchange, 64-66 Wingate Square
London SW4 0AF

Registered Address

7 Tufton Street
London SW1P 3QB

The STI Clinic is owned and operated by Online Medical Services Limited. Any medical service required is contracted to be provided by Online Clinic (UK) Limited, which is licensed by the Care Quality Commission. Testing is undertaken at The Doctors Laboratory, which is registered with Clinical Pathology Accreditation.

  • The Doctors Laboratory
  • Clinical Pathology Accreditation logoClinical Pathology Accreditation no. 1954
  • Information Commissioner's OfficeData Protection Act registered
    ICO registration no. Z2782183
Visa and Visa Debit accepted Master accepted American Express accepted